‘We Need Medicare for All’: Massive Coronavirus Job Losses Expose Obvious Failure of Employer-Based Insurance

After millions of Americans abruptly lost their jobs this month due to the coronavirus, resulting in a record-shattering 3.28 million unemployment claims in one week, Medicare for All advocates are pointing to the crisis as the latest and clearest evidence that the U.S. must abandon its for-profit healthcare system once and for all.

I’ve been told people like ‘choice’ when it comes to healthcare, the 3 million people fired this week didn’t have any choice when losing their health insurance.”
—Adam H. Johnson, The Appeal

Nearly half of the American population has health insurance through their jobs, a system which critics—including Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.)—have long said is precarious for millions of workers.

With restaurants, retail stores, and other businesses closing their doors across the country to help stop the spread of the coronavirus, officially known as COVID-19, millions of workers could now be forced to seek coverage through the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA), through the Affordable Care Act, or through Medicaid. 

Highlighting the March 2020 spike in a graph showing U.S. jobless claims over the past five decades, advocacy group Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP) issued a reminder that “under Medicare for All, nobody would have to worry about health coverage after losing their job.”

The image, Sanders’ campaign advisor, David Sirota, tweeted, “explains one of the reasons why employer-based private health insurance is extremely bad.”

Other critics suggested the coronavirus pandemic should mark the end of claims made by politicians and commentators that tying health coverage to one’s employment is beneficial for workers and the economy.

“You have zero excuse for supporting a candidate who opposes Medicare for All at this point,” podcast host Benjamin Dixon tweeted. “3.3 million people just lost their ‘if you like your employer benefits you can keep them’ benefits. Healthcare can never again be tied to employment.”

As Fordham University professor Ashar Foley wrote in an op-ed at Common Dreams Wednesday, the explosion of jobless claims and the resulting crisis of uninsured and underinsured Americans which is likely to follow is just one way in which the coronavirus pandemic has proven the private, for-profit health insurance model to be unsustainable and dangerous:

It is too early to say which countries will prove most successful in containing the virus, but there are indications that those with single-payer systems have the advantage.

As Helen Buckingham of the Nuffield Trust told the Washington Post, the U.K.’s National Health Service is well-positioned to cope. It has a clear and comprehensive emergency planning structure with the ability to optimize resource use, even after years of government budget cuts.

Federalized health care means centralized patient information. As Kelsey Piper reported for Vox, Taiwan’s ability to get information quickly from citizens’ medical files, combined with proactive containment, enabled testing for the virus as early as December. Despite high traffic with mainland China, Taiwan only had 45 confirmed cases of the disease and one death in early March.

Similarly, South Korea’s aggressive testing and universal coverage helped the country “flatten the curve” more effectively than any other so far.

“If we continue to put our political and economic ideologies ahead of our health, we stand to lose everything,” Foley wrote.

Read ‘We Need Medicare for All’: Massive Coronavirus Job Losses Expose Obvious Failure of Employer-Based Insurance on Common Dreams

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *